Visje69 meets ‘Random’

Recenlty it was decided a column would be regularly posted on the SoccerProject Newsletter. Not a bad idea, I first thought, until we discussed the first subject: Random….
First I thought of killing myself, no way was I doing that!! But then again I started thinking writing this was a better option. I met a huge task to describe and discuss the most controversial subject in the Soccerproject history. As for myself I’m not the perfect person to say anything about that, since my team has won only one game in two seasons time. Because of the entire change in my team I haven’t found the time to study upon the random. So therefore I went looking for some games that ended with the ’smallest’ difference or an ‘unjust’ draw. Where else to start my quest than on the forum, THE place where managers make each other’s life a living hell.
After a few pages I ran into a manager (not literally of course) that claimed the random had become worse, but as fast as he put on that statement it was taken off the edge by some more experienced managers in the game. A change in random seems excluded, because Sjarel should have said something about it then.
The first two matches that I investigate in my own division, nothing strange happened there. First we have a 0-0 draw with a line difference of 1 and in the other game there was a 0-1 victory with a line difference of 2 in the advantage of the winning team. Also in the next two matches that I watched, nothing strange happened. It seems like random doesn’t strike in my division? Or maybe Sjarel loves me and saves me from Random? So I went to division A. The first match between the glassbell and rollerball was very close but won by rollerball despite of a line advantage of 7! But also in the other 5 close games in A, nothing strange happened. So after investigating 27 games in E12, A, B1, B2 and B3, there was only one case that could be seen as a case of random. In the match between Team#soad and FC Diepenbeek, where the home team had a line advantage of 3, but the match ended in a 0-0 draw. Not that much of a surprise right? My personal conclusion: The random is not so marked as most people think (certainly not with me, thank you Sjarel!), but it seems like that because people complain when it works in their disadvantage!! But since I’m not playing this game alone, more opinions are required.
So I looked for some managers that knew more about this and asked for their reactions.
bLo0dHunt3r: “Well, everyone is fanatical about the random, but I’m glad that it’s there. A team that can’t manage to score, can play a superb game, but it shall never win. It makes it more realistic, you’re a trainer with a worked out strategy, but in the end it’s up to the players. Without the random, everything would be too determined.”
Alisa: “Oh well, of course it’s a shame for the team that was better and lost. But in real life it happens too that the better team loses (Vitesse – Ajax, 4-2). Because of that there still is some tension in the game. Otherwise if you played a game between an A and a D team, you would know beforehand that the A-team would win.
Random isn’t only to be found in matches, this shows after I heard this story from Loreback (aka David Joosen): “I had a youth coordinator that didn’t give me enough players, and if I received one after all, he was way too aggressive! So I decided to fire my youth coordinator and hire a new one. But when I looked back to my old one, I saw that in his new team, he immediately delivered a superb player! So you see that random strikes everywhere!”
Also the story of Akki makes us think about the random: “I have the bad luck that 5 times in a row, my youth player was rejected because of the random, my patience is running out. Random itself should be there, I don’t mind that you lose a game once against a team that’s supposed to be weaker, it happens in real life too, but it has to be realistic. You shouldn’t lose 5 games against a weaker opponent in one season, but 2 to 3 times is all right.
To make a final conclusion, after this investigation we did not get much further. (Wasted all this valuable time!) Random is hitting randomly but not as bad as most people think. Random doesn’t have to change. And for the managers who think they are harmed by the random, don’t worry, because it doesn’t occur that much and only makes the game more realistic. If perhaps you feel the uncontrollable urge to kick your computer out of the window now, try to reconsider, because there are better options
By Visje69
We want to thank Sybke for this wonderful cartoon. She won our cartoon contest this week. Several other people did a good job as well, they might want to try again next week. And if you’d like to see your cartoon in the newsletter, please enter our contest on the forum!